HERD ABOUT IT?
by Ana Grarian
Why does Israel keep Palestinians separated from the water and cropland they need to feed themselves?
Farmer’s who have followed the trend into mono-culture, must sell a single commodity to gain access into the capitalist economy. Living on a very narrow margin makes them hesitant to try anything other than what the seed and feed “experts” recommend.
In coal mining towns in WV, the growing of gardens was made difficult due to lack of arable land or through zoning regulations.
WHY?
If miner’s couldn’t feed themselves, they wouldn’t go out on strike.

by Ana Grarian on Tue, Jun 15, 2010
Comments Off
HERD ABOUT IT?
by Ana Grarian
Ana is on a field trip through the mid-west with a group of church folk. We are a varied group from California to New York, Texas to Kentucky, men and women ages 20 something to 70 something. Vegan, vegetarian and omnivore. Urban, suburban, farm folk with a passion for sustainable agriculture, just food systems, and healthy foods. Many have a background in ministry.
We have heard some exemplary lectures from Dr. Ellen Davis a Professor of Old Testament and Practical Theology, at Duke University, and close friend of Ana’s patron saint Wendell Berry.
Dr. Davis tells us the story from a new perspective, that of an agrarian. Close to one hundred percent of ancient people’s would have been farmers, shepherds and gardeners. Land, tillable land, was not a marketable quantity in ancient Israel. Though a home or business within the city walls could be bought or sold, arable land was a covenanted entity.
Land was held it in covenant with God. A person who could not pay their debts (usually taxes) would sell their children, or themselves into indentured servitude, before selling their land, because this gave them an opportunity to work off the debt. In the event that land was lost, the extended family was obligated to try to redeem the land.
We are all familiar with the phrase “from dust you came to dust you shall return”, or “ashes to ashes, dust to dust”, from funeral services. The implication that we came from nothing and will return to nothing, but according to Dr. Davis that “nothing” idea is wrong. The correct translation is more like “arable soil” and is used in terms of being our progenitor. We are “Adam from Adamah” a red human from the red soil. Humans from humus. And there are other creation stories that illustrate man as having been formed from the earth.
And not just the first humans. Daily we are recreated from the earth, from the soil in which our food grows. The earth will belong to it’s creator, whomever you perceive that to be, long after we are gone. In the meantime we are invited to share in an abundance from which we gain life. Do we want that to be a healthy and just life, or one polluted by our own hands?
The grower of trees, the gardener, the man born to farming, whose hands reach into the ground and sprout, to him the soil is a divine drug. He enters into death yearly, and comes back rejoicing. He has seen the light lie down in the dung heap, and rise again in the corn. His thought passes along the row ends like a mole. What miraculous seed has he swallowed that the unending sentence of his love flows out of his mouth like a vine clinging in the sunlight, and like water descending in the dark? The Man Born to Farming copyright Wendell BerryPost a comment...
by Ana Grarian on Wed, Jun 9, 2010
Comments Off

The Pelican by John Cole via thetimes -tribune.com
by Ana Grarian on Wed, Jun 9, 2010
Comments Off
HERD ABOUT IT?
by Ana Grarian
CNY is one of those places with capricious weather. This is the time when one of our local communities puts on a days long festival to celebrate the amazing variety of people and opportunities in the area. OK – they also celebrate the reclaiming of the town by residents, just after the students leave and just before the tourists arrive full blast. It is a full on explosion of the ideas and passions of community life.
It almost always coincides with huge rainstorms.

This year the parade went off without a hitch. The weather was beautiful. Preceeded by a foot race and over an hour and a half long, there were scout troops and clowns, the SPCA and the vet school, a horse and wagon, roller derby women and a chain saw band.
For a great photomontage see my friends slide show at tinytowntimes.com
(http://tinytowntimes.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=749:2010-ithaca-festival-parade-slideshow&catid=53:sideshows)
Friday and Saturday the weather continued sunny and a little too hot and humid for me. There was rain overnight to the delight of gardeners, but sun for the vendors of food and crafts, and the musicians, dancers, etc. A totally odd bit of weather for this festival. Perhaps using the theme “Singing in the Rain” had done it’s trick to fend off the gods.
Ah – but there was still Sunday to come. Sunday the festivities move to the park at the end of the lake. A beautiful sea of green lawn dotted with soaring trees, and unfortunately, a beach that was closed decades ago due to pollution. But still – a lovely spot for families to spend the day with neighbors and friends and enjoy a party.
The food and craft vendors came. There were to be pony rides. A local medieval history group came in period garb with fencers and fighters, the King and Queen, activities for children, musicians and other medival fare. Other tents held dancers, and musicians of varied styles from drum circles to bagpipers. A large tent provided folks with information on electric cars, solar heating, sustainable agriculture, recycling. You name it – if it was green – it was there.
The day started out with rain which then seemed to die out in time for folks to set out their wares. Shortly the temperature soared and everyone was awash in sweat and applying sun screen. But there was a breeze – so- go on with the merry making. Soon the winds picked up and the temperature dove. The tornado went well to the south of town, but the winds were still enough to close down some tents. The medieval knights were doomed to return to their castles. I searched amongst the food vendors for someone who was serving hot coffee. Soon it was only cold, the winds having passed us by. Then of course, as exhibitors packed up and headed home, the rain returned.
A perfectly normal day in CNY for a festival.
Post a comment...by Ana Grarian on Thu, Jun 3, 2010
HERD ABOUT IT?
by Ana Grarian
Having once put his hand into the ground
seeding there what he hopes will outlast him,
a man has made a marriage with his place,
and if he leaves it his flesh will ache to go back.
-Wendell Berry
My cousins and I know what it is to ache for a place. Our fathers came from the Adirondacks, and though they may not have “put their hands into the ground” in the sense of farming, they certainly were tied to the land by hunting, fishing and love of place. Their livelihood was tied to its natural resources. As solitary people they found solace in the quiet of the woods, though anyone who has been deep in the woods knows its quiet is not silence but an insulation from unnatural sound. Even as I sit here in my apartment on a very tree filled block, the joyous bird talk after a night of rain, belies the idea of a silent wood. We ache to be there. If there was work to be had, we would be there. We return often and often together. Our earliest and fondest memories are of sharing family time there. We are tied to the community through experience and family stories. We spend time and energy to pass this treasure onto our children and grandchildren.
In today’s urban, chaotic, move – move – move society do people still experience this attachment to place?? Perhaps. I have been chased out twice now by city folk who, having moved to the country, have then worked hard to bring Manhattan along with them. I ache to go back, break up the concrete, and put my hands into the soil. This is happening now in Detroit. I will be going to see it soon. And though I don’t belittle the hardship that the people of that once thriving metropolis have endured, I can’t help seeing this opportunity to reclaim the land of steel and concrete into something more naturally productive, as a plus. I have just begun to read “Welcome to Utopia” by Karen Valby. Valby calls it “a moving elegy for a proud American way of life”. In reading that, I die a little. Valby writes,“but what I didn’t presume to understand about Utopia was what was going on in the minds of those who chose to stay, the people whose deepest desire was to make a home for themselves down the street from where their parents lived and their grandparents were buried. Roots are rare these days. So many of us have lost connection to the ground.” Wallace Stegner said that we Americans divide into two groups, boomers and stickers. The boomers are always thinking that something is better somewhere else, that whatever they have or whatever they are is no good. That’s what commercials have taught us. We can never be sure that our detergent, car, job is best. So what? Does it serve our purpose? Clean well enough? Pay the bills? If we’d just stop worrying about status, we’d have time to connect with people and activities and places that really matter. Someone I know has made a career of entertaining children. He doesn’t make a lot of money at it. He doesn’t have a fancy tour bus. No groupies. But he has spent his life doing something he loves, and doing it well. And by the grace of God he has a life partner who cherishes him for who he is, not what he earns. I have a friend who has moved to a new job in a new city. She recently confided to me that she is lonely. Lonely for real friendship. Someone to connect to. Though she is active in several groups, the connection ends when the meeting does. She has few people with whom to go to a movie , or discuss a book or idea. I feel this myself. Though I am involved with a group of folks who are passionately involved in protecting the environment, we always seem to be rushing off to the next thing. Yet as farmers we always seemed to have time to stop the tractor a few minutes when we passed the neighbor in their yard, meet the letter or paper carrier at the mailbox, or chat at the feed mill or grocery. Because we knew each other, sickness or death brought hand made and hand delivered casseroles, cakes and offers of help. Without a plethora of restaurants to tempt us, dish to pass events were exciting opportunities to show off our best dishes and to enjoy a variety of offerings from the community. An inexpensive but filling and fulfilling evening out, sharing news and gossip. In today’s society marriage has little allure except for the big party and the fancy dress. The idea of marriage to place, would most likely bring puzzled stares from most youth. And yet how can we hope to have a sustainable world if our homes, friends, jobs, lives are disposable?Cash them in and move to the next best thing. We can’t both treat the world as temporary, and preserve it for the future.
by Ana Grarian on Thu, May 27, 2010
Comments Off
HERD ABOUT IT!
by Ana Grarian
Ana was in Syracuse last night for a presentation on “Green Infrastructure”. The presentation was about retrofitting Syracuse to better handle runoff water so that it didn’t cause pollution of lakes and streams, and presented less erosion. Storm water runoff sweeps pollutants from hard surfaces directly into streams, or is channeled through the storm sewers into the municipal waste system. This rapid influx of water means the treatment plants are overtaxed and end up discharging untreated sewage into the water.
One of the goals is to make the water in local streams suitable for people to touch without getting sick.
Huh, good idea. A creek walk is being planned that will allow residents a pleasant place to walk along the creek, and serve as a demonstration of different methods of water catchment and diversion. The idea is to catch water runoff from roofs, roads and parking lots so that it can more slowly be absorbed into the ground, and filter into the aquifers. Come to find out that when people have access to their streams and rivers – they care about them more. It seems this particular creek has been walled in, to the extent that, many residents didn’t even know where it was.
Of course this made Ana think about the rural areas she loves.
One of the measures of the “backwardness” of an area is the “amount of unpaved roads” that exist. When Ana first moved to CNY there were many sections of unpaved roads. The only real problem with them was that you should drive slower on them. In the winter they were better because they didn’t ice as badly. Turns out they also don’t have the runoff problems of paved roads. Same could be said of my dirt driveway – and you know – I’m not sure why everyone wants to pave their driveway – and then have to maintain that with applications of oil and sealant. (petro dollars)
Syracuse is working with different types of pavement that allow for water to filter through rather than runoff to the side of the street into the sewers. Hmmmm. Seems like the folks who did Ithaca’s streets in bricks a hundred years ago, knew what they were doing. Unfortunately the engineers have not figured out how to make the underlayment work for the heavier vehicles on the road today.
Another old/new idea is a cistern.
There was a day when every house had a cistern in the cellar, that caught roof runoff, or at least a rain barrel. This water was used for laundry and scrubbing floors and even baths. Someone shared how in many places the use of cached water has become illegal. I’m not sure why that came about. I know gray-water systems are illegal in some places too. Yet reusing water for say – flushing toilets – is a great method of conservation.
Syracuse is planting trees which help to make use of the water going into the ground, as well as clean the air, provide aethestic beauty, and help to keep the city naturally cooler. There are well placed and planned gardens which make use of runoff water, slowing the flow and allowing for natural absorption into the soil.
Green roofs which prolong the life of the roof, can provide places for urban farming, help with cooling and heating costs, are beautiful, and prevent runoff. When asked about the structural strength needed for the added weight, it was pointed out, that often the old buildings were suitable, while newer construction had been built to “tighter standards” and thus could not support the added weight. Huh – old fashioned buildings were stronger?
Yeah – they also had windows that would open and close which reduces need for air conditioning (but I digress).
There is a lot of good work going on in Syracuse and other cities. It turns out that rain is not just a nuisance, it’s a neccesary part of our water system, and when you let people be in touch with the natural systems such as streams and creeks, they are more likely to respect that.
Country folk could have told them. We probably did. Turns out we knew what we were talking about.
by Ana Grarian on Tue, May 25, 2010
Comments Off
HERD ABOUT IT?
by Ana Grarian

Yesterday Ana went to the NYS Capitol in Albany along with, Neighbors United For the Fingerlakes, Shaleshock and about 20 other regional environmental citizen groups, to meet with legislators, for a day of lobbying to promote the passage of the Englebright/Addabbo bills to put a moratorium on drilling in the Marcellus Shale in NYS.
Given that the DEC will soon complete its woefully inadequate general environmental impact study, which could allow for permitting to begin as early as December of this year, it is important to have this bill signed during this legislative session.
The Englebright /Addabbo bill would put a moratorium on drilling until 120 days after the EPA completes a Congressionally ordered study on the environmental impact of horizontal slick-water hydro-fracking.
The group Ana was with, met with representatives from the offices of Sen. Malcolm Smith, Sen.Carl Kruger, and Sen. Charles Fuschillo. Our meetings went well and were encouraging, in that, the Senators are also concerned about the negative impacts to the NYS environment and quality of life, from hydrofracking. Unfortunately at this time the senators are not ready to cosponsor the bill. Elections are coming and these downstate representatives are currently more afraid of the political backlash from Republican spin (that somehow passage of this bill is a vote against upstate jobs) than they are from regular voters.
It is important to let our government officials know where the voters stand on the issues. And when the issue can be spun through an upstate/downstate hostility, it is even more important that voters from all over the state urge legislators to back environmentally sound policies.
Pete Grannis commissioner of the DEC has already given downstate representatives a free pass in their own districts to avoid this fight. NY City’s watershed has been placed under different, more restrictive, rules for drilling and protecting water supplies.
We need an upstate-downstate alliance to protect the drinking water for ALL of us. After all the food we produce in CNY goes to feed NYC. If you want healthy food, you need healthy farmers, livestock and crops.
Another team went to visit some upstate representatives. Ana Is relieved to hear that Sen Nazzolio and Assemblyperson Finch are committed to making sure the Auburn Waste Water Treatment Plant does not illegally take in toxic waste water from fracking sites. Waste water is being trucked out of PA to other states because there are not enough facilities with the technology to successfully clean the fluids of toxic chemicals and radioactivity.
This was Ana’s second trip to Albany and it is nice to learn that our representatives will take the time to hear from ordinary citizens.
by Ana Grarian on Tue, May 11, 2010
Comments Off
HERD ABOUT IT?
by Ana Grarian
Are we partly to blame for today’s agricultural methods and how does it tie into obesity and other food health issues? I started thinking about my own misuse of food and my health issues. This started me thinking about food in our culture which led me to think about our fast food notion of sex.

Food on the run, in our face all the time, and yet unsatisfying.
Sex everywhere we look, and yet demeaning and unsatisfying.
Two essential parts of life that should be communal and yet have become very solitary.
Rabbi Achia ben Yeshaya said: One who purchases grain in the marketplace—to what may such a person be likened? To an infant whose mother died, and they pass him from door to door among wet-nurses and [still] the baby is not satisfied. One who buys bread in the marketplace—to what may such a person be likened? It is as if he is dead and buried. But one who eats from his own (what one has grown himself), is like an infant raised at his mother’s breasts.— Avot de Rabbi Natan 31:1
In today’s marketplace this is more true than we like to acknowledge. Even fresh fruits and vegetables are less nutritious due to soil depletion and harvesting while still immature. Increasingly our processed food contains levels of toxins that will kill us. The other day I saw a can of soup that contained 45% of the daily allowance of sodium in one serving. There is also something unsatisfying about having too much.
Weight loss counselors have told us that in order to limit our food intake, to be satisfied with less, and thus healthier (in both purse and waistline), we should eat deliberately. Set the table, turn off the TV, set our forks down between bites. I was just reminded of an admonishment to not bring a book to the table. Dinner was a time of sharing our day with one another. Even breakfast was a time of planning the day ahead. Would we need so many communication devices if we just sat down together and listened?
These communal acts of life, have become solitary and thus less fulfilling. If you have ever grown a garden, even one tomato plant, perhaps even just a Chia Pet, you know that there is satisfaction in it. To harvest a garden, or even to bring home deliberately chosen produce, and create a meal, is satisfying in so many more ways than throwing a plastic tray in the microwave. To share that creation with family and friends increases the pleasure.
I am reminded here of how the cats would place themselves on the bench next to my husband and I at meal time. With the kids grown and away, the pets became an integral part of our meal time. Ignoring them for too long brought a paw to the knee or a nose rub to the elbow, and a feeling of appreciation.
Food and sex are part and parcel of the continuation of life. Good nutrition means a life healthy enough and long enough to reproduce. Sex is a communal act, but in our chaotic Western lifestyle, has lost the communion aspect. Like everything else it has been turned into a concern about how much, how long, how often. It has become an opportunity to sell us a product, and that product is too often the sex itself.
Pornography is rampant and becoming more and more violent. My thought on this is that since we are only experiencing the sex act in porn with two of our senses, sight and sound, it requires more and more stimulation to acheive the same affect. Since the people on screen are only there to stimulate us, we accept the violence done to them. Then perversely we accept that violence as normal.
Like eating, sex should involve all of our senses. A long term couple knows each others smell and feel and sound and taste. Even our intellectual interaction is part of the mix. I suppose this might be part of knowing our clan, just as different types of the same beetle recognize each other by their mating ritual.
Our fast food sex is nowhere near as satiating as true communal sex. We may have sex thrown in our face 24/7, it may be more available either for hire or with casual acquaintences, or machines or blow up babes, but it is not as satisfying. Our fixation with oral sex may be a reflection of our hunger for more satisfying relationship.
How does this apply to agrarianism? I think our disconnection from the natural ebb and flow of life is reflected in our attitude toward food, possessions and sex. The constant barrage of advertising telling us we aren’t good enough, what we have isn’t good enough, and what we’re getting isn’t good enough, has separated us from the land, each other and even ourselves. We are constantly trying to make ourselves into what Madison Avenue and Hollywood sell us as good. But like trying to please tyrannical parent we will never be good enough for them.
by Ana Grarian on Mon, May 3, 2010
HERD ABOUT IT?
by Ana Grarian
My father used to say “You eat a pound of dirt a day”. This proverb was usually in response to something falling on the floor and was an “ok” to brush it off and eat it. Today we use the “5 second rule”. Turns out my father was more correct than I imagined, though perhaps, he knew the origins of the phrase.
For every unit of food we consume, using the conventional agricultural methods employed in the U.S., six times that amount of topsoil is lost. Since, according to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, the average person eats a ton of food each year, that works out to 12,000 pounds (5,443 kilograms) of topsoil.
http://www.odemagazine.com/doc/69/dirt/
20th century or what is now called “conventional” agriculture is very wasteful of soil, as well as water and nutrients. I remember being puzzled at seeing the seedbed of farm fields laying so much lower than the edges of the field. This didn’t make sense to me. As a gardener I felt the productive land should be higher. After all manure was added to the soil. Crop residues were plowed in. In a well tended home garden the soil becomes deeper and better as composted material is mulched around plants and then turned into the soil.
I thought it must be a trick of the eye. Certainly there could be compression as larger tractors and bigger equipment was used to accomplish normal tasks in less time. What I didn’t realize was how much normal farm practice had changed during my lifetime.
Before the World Wars brought us the petrochemical era, cultivation and use of the land for growing crops was more beneficial, both to the consumer and to the soil. As we have depleted our soils, our produce has also become depleted of vitamins and minerals.
When livestock were bedded with straw and ate a diet richer in dry matter, the manure returned and plowed into the soil, returned nutrients as well as substance to the fields. Before the mono-cultures of corn and soybeans became entrenched, rotation of crops meant that most fields had a crop growing the whole year. This protected the soil from run off. Though we didn’t know it at the time it also helped with Carbon sequestration and hindered global warming by reflecting rather than absorbing heat from the sun. Before we separated livestock and crops onto separate farms and increasingly into separate areas of the country, nutrients were returned to the soils from whence they came. Crop rotation allowed one type of plant to return nutrients to the soil that had been depleted by a different crop.
And as the population is more and more removed from their food sources, their waste stock is not returned to the soil either. Nearly one-fourth of municipal waste is thought to be from food scraps and lawn waste. Another source of nutrient depletion that instead of being returned to the field is going to waste in landfills and we are substituting harmful petrochemicals.
Have you had the opportunity to watch a compost pile? Or perhaps to repeatedly walk a forest trail and watch a tree decompose? In my yard we had a huge old tree stump. It must have been three foot in diameter. Around the base of it I had a garden. The soil there was so wonderful as the tree stump shed bits and peices of itself and they were chewed up and excreted by a plethora of bugs and worms. The soil would flow through your hands and smelled so wonderful. Not to mention the stump provided many afternoons of interesting exploration with my grandchildren.
Our lives and practices should reflect that natural cycle. What we take with one hand we should return with the other. The problem with measuring value with money, is that it limits us and others from continuing to prosper. Perhaps we should put all those greenbacks into the compost piles instead of Goldman Sachs. A soil bank is actually a much better investment.
by Ana Grarian on Mon, Apr 26, 2010
HERD ABOUT IT?
by Ana Grarian
For months now there has been an unusual alliance between the folks in metropolitan NY City and those in rural Upstate NY. Concerned about their own water supply, people and officials from NYC have joined in the fight against unsafe slick water fracking for fossil gas in the Marcellus Shale. Now Commissioner Pete Grannis seeks to break that alliance by offering separate more stringent rules for the NYC and Syracuse watersheds that in effect bans drilling in those watersheds.
NY State Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) Commissioner Pete Grannis announced that “due to the unique issues related to the protection of New York City and Syracuse drinking water supplies” applications to drill in those watersheds will require a case-by-case environmental review process to “establish whether appropriate measures to mitigate potential impacts can be developed”.
That leaves the rest of us in grave danger.
Thank you to NYS Assembly Speaker Sheldon SIlver for speaking out on behalf of the rest of the residents of NYS….
“While I am pleased that the Department of Environmental Conservation has added an additional level of scrutiny to permit applications for drilling in the New York City and Syracuse watersheds, I strongly believe New York State should take no further action towards the approval of permits in any drinking water sensitive area anywhere in New York State until the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency completes its study of hydrofracking and companies are required to fully disclose all chemicals used in the drilling process. There is nothing more important than the safety of our water supply and protecting the health and welfare of our citizens. We simply cannot move forward until we have all the facts. “
http://assembly.state.ny.us/Press/20100423/
Respectfully Mr. Silver, Is there anywhere in NYS that is not a
“drinking water sensitive area”?
I’m kind of sensitive about my well and my town’s well, and the lakes which provide drinking water for many small towns in NYS.
I think John Quigley, the recently confirmed secretary of Pennsylvania’s Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, said it well when he accused the PA Legislature of: “using gas revenues from state forests as a “crack cocaine fix” to balance the state budget”.
Looking only at revenues from gas drilling without taking into account all of the costs to the public and the environment will lead us down a road paved with Fool’s Gold ending at a massive Brownfield Site and the bill for cleaning it up.
The Faces of Frackland
http://pafaces.wordpress.com/2010/04/23/an-a1-industrial-zone/
Proudly using Dynamic Headers by Nicasio WordPress Design
by Ana Grarian on Sun, Jun 20, 2010
1 Comment